The Race Equity in Employment Task Force welcomes the final report ‘From a Welfare State to a Working State’ by Alan Milburn published yesterday.
The report makes key recommendations that will see the system rebuilt for young people, but any attempt to save a lost generation will not succeed as long as racism continues to shape who gets a fair chance at work.
In No Talent Wasted, the Task Force called for a system overhaul to tackle the crisis facing young people – one which underscored the need to focus on supporting young people, changing employer behaviour, and addressing systemic barriers.
The Milburn Review does just that – it details changes that need to happen across education, health, employment, youth participation, care, justice, and beyond – identifying three mandatory priority-cohort groups across which Black, Asian, and Mixed Heritage people are over-represented. Crucially, it supports the Task Force’s key call for ethnicity-disaggregated data to monitor participation and outcomes, and we would welcome a Government commitment to ensure that NEET datasets collect and publish ethnicity breakdowns.
However, we know that data collection does not go far enough. The evidence already shows that the gaps for Black, Asian and Mixed Heritage young people persist through successive policy cycles, not despite them, because each cycle resets the accountability clock without resolving the underlying structural failure.
For Black, Asian, and Mixed Heritage young people, the barriers to work do not stem from a lack of aspiration but the enduring impact of racial discrimination and unequal opportunity. 48% of ethnic minority young people have reported experiencing prejudice and discrimination at work. Black, African, and Caribbean young people face the highest NEET rate.
Crucially, the chances for Black, Asian, and Mixed Heritage young people who are NEET to escape are much lower, as they experiences disproportionately higher rates of unemployment in older age groups.
We welcome the recommendation to introduce mandatory ethnicity-disaggregated data collection, but this approach must be matched by a clear national target to eliminate racial disparities in employment outcomes for 16-24-year-olds by 2035. Tracking outcomes beyond entry into work is equally important, ensuring young people are progressing into secure, well-paid employment rather than becoming trapped in low-paid, insecure roles. This goal could be delivered by stretching targets for the new Youth Opportunity Service, Participation Agreements, Devolution Deals, and ensuring the market is responsive to the opportunities and risks presented amidst technological advancements such as AI. Without this, the new architecture risks being legally compliant but effectively blind to race.
The devolution agenda presents a significant opportunity to drive progress towards a national target. Local leaders are best placed to understand and respond to the specific racial inequalities affecting their communities, but devolution must be underpinned by consistent ethnicity-disaggregated data collection, robust accountability mechanisms and targeted action. Otherwise, it risks devolving accountability.
Moving beyond blind recruitment, government, employers and education providers should adopt a comprehensive package of anti-racist measures spanning careers advice, work experience, apprenticeships, recruitment, progression and retention. Only a whole-system approach will address the discrimination and structural barriers that continue to limit opportunities for many Black, Asian and Mixed Heritage young people.
The next generation deserves more than a pathway into work. They deserve a labour market free from the racial discrimination and unequal treatment that continue to shape life chances across Britain.
Dr Jeremy Crook OBE, Chief Executive, Action for Race Equality and co-convenor of the Race Equity in Employment Task Force, said:
ARE welcomes the Milburn Review recommendations. He is right to say that we must build an entirely different system over 10 years. But a new system will not deliver different outcomes unless it confronts a longstanding reality: many Black, Asian and Mixed Heritage young people face discrimination in the labour market, regardless of their qualifications, skills or ambition.
It’s important for government to remove the barriers preventing a million young people from accessing pathways to good employment. We must have a welfare system that supports and enables young people, with financial benefits they can live on. But tackling youth exclusion also requires a clear commitment to addressing racial disparities in access to opportunities, apprenticeships, progression and secure work, so that every young person has a fair chance to succeed.“
Sandra Kerr CBE, Business in the Community, Race Equality Director and co-convenor of the Race Equity in Employment Task Force, said:
I am delighted to see the publication of the Milburn Review final report. I am passionate about evidence-based action, and I welcome the recognition of the importance of capturing ethnicity data in this report. Better data will enable the UK to celebrate the inclusive progression of all young people in opportunities, training and work regardless of demographic group, sex, disability, location and social background, so that we can be assured that change and progress is happening for all young people, wherever they live and whatever their backgrounds.
I look forward to seeing the momentum build around the findings and will support in the delivery of the vital actions to bring the changes to life in any way that I can.”
About the Race Equity in Employment Task Force
The Race Equity in Employment Task Force brought together racial justice experts, charity and business leaders, academics, and local and national government officials, and elected representatives to address persistent racial inequalities for Black, Asian, and Mixed Heritage young people aged 16-24 in the UK labour market.
Convened by Action for Race Equality in partnership with Business in the Community and chaired by Prime Minister Andy Burnham in his former capacity as the Mayor of Greater Manchester, the Task Force leveraged rigorous data, research, and lived experience to outline actionable policy reform reflecting a national government focus on boosting UK growth and productivity, and a national mission to support young people to thrive. Recognising the growing urgency as over one million 16- to 24-year-olds in the UK are not in employment, education, or training (NEET), The Task Force aimed to catalyse long-term, systemic change, ensuring that all young people, regardless of their ethnicity, have equitable access to meaningful and sustainable employment opportunities.




